© Planetlemans - Marcel ten Caat
In 2008 the fight was on between Van Merksteijn Motorsport and Team Essex, both racing their Porsche RS Spyders. They had quite a nice fight, something that people hoped to see again in 2009. The two Porsches tried to fight each other this year, but it was soon clear who was the best team out in the LMP2 category. Unfortunately LMP2 had a high attrition rate again in 2009.
5-NAVI Team Goh: The winning car of 2008 was unable to repeat this performance in 2009. For the first eight hours the Japanese Porsche RS Spyder was close to the Essex Porsche but two extra pit stops before midnight meant the car lost two laps. Shortly after midnight a front bodywork change meant the loss of another two laps and a trip through the gravel later in the night meant the chances of winning had kind of vanished. Around 1.45 p.m. Seiji Ara hit the guardrail at the Playstation chicane before going through the tyre barriers, destroying the #5 Porsche RS Spyder.
24-OAK Racing: Despite problems with the front bodywork on the #24 Pescarolo-Mazda the OAK Racing car of Nicolet, Hein and Yvon did well in the remainder of the race. Richard Hein had a minor spin during the night but all the way until about an hour and fifteen minutes before the end of the race there wasn’t a problem and the #24 was running fourth in class. At 1.50 p.m. the car came into the box with an engine problem but the team sorted the problem and sent out the car in time to take the chequered flag. With the #5 Porsche crashed out it meant the OAK Racing team took third in LMP2.
25-RML: Unfortunately it was another case of déjà vu for RML at Le Mans. Despite a rather trouble free first part of the race. At 2.17 p.m. the Lola Mazda came in to have its engine checked and after the plugs were replaced Erdos was sent out again. Newton and Dyson went out for stints and again had no problems, but just after 10 o’clock in the morning while running in fourth place Erdos suddenly lost power and not much later the Lola Mazda was retired with the third engine failure of the season. After identical problems at Barcelona and Spa it remains to be seen what the team will do post-Le Mans.
26-Bruichladdich-Bruneau: A rather disastrous weekend for the Bruichladdich-Bruneau team. Marc Rostan and Pierre Bruneau completed one stint before handing over to Tim Greaves. Unfortunately just after 7.30 pm Greaves was literally pushed off the track by the #009 Aston Martin at the Ford Chicane, hit the wall and then slammed into the tyre barriers at the pit entrance. As a result the rear of the Radical suffered serious damage, but Greaves managed to get back into the pit. Several hours later (just after 2 a.m.) it was back in the race, but one hour later it was back in for another long stop, something that happened once more at 5 a.m. At 6.30 the team withdrew the car after suffering an engine failure and a fuel leak.
30-Racing Box: The Racing Box Lola Judd wasn’t able to repeat the success from the opening race of the LMS. But at least Racing Box made it into the race this year. Already in the opening hours the team suffered problems and had bodywork fixed. Through the night things went reasonably well until Matteo Bobbi ended up in the gravel trap at 4.30 and only managed to get away some twenty minutes later. Just after 5 the car went straight into a wall and the team lost another 30 minutes in the pit. One hour later the race came to an end when engine expired.
31-Team Essex: Having finished second in 2008 the Team Essex Porsche RS Spyder was in a league of its own in 2009. The Team Goh Porsche was the only car that was able to follow the Danish entry, but when that car hit trouble it was a matter of finishing and winning the class. There was no rush in completing pit stops as the opposition dropped out of the race and the team took its time to replace parts. After 24 hours the #31 Porsche crossed the line in first place, the Elgaard-Collard-Poulsen car finished 14 laps ahead of the second placed car. A complete walk-over for Team Essex.
32-Barazi Epsilon: Barazi, Moseley and Bennett had a rather anonymous race. In the first couple of hours the car did its laps and had slowly moved up into fifth place before losing 50 minutes in the pit with throttle problems. After that the car went out in eighth place and stayed in that position for the entire night. Early in the morning a battery was changed, which cost the team another 10 minutes. Just before eleven o’clock Barazi came into the box again and the team started working on a problem with the exhaust. One hour later Bennett went and took the car over the finish. Eventually the Zytek 07S was classified fourth in LMP2.
33-Speedy Racing Team Sebah: Best of the rest in LMP2 this year. Like in 2008 the Porsche RS Spyders were no match for the Lola. As the #33 was much quicker than the other cars the team had rather uneventful race. At night Pompidou had to stop a bit longer for some small repairs and then he went straight twice. Later in the night and early in the morning three other longer stops were made for small repairs. Two similar stops were made in the final hour. After six hours the gap to the leading Porsche was 2 laps, at 12 hours it had gone to six laps and at the finish it was 14 laps. Yet the OAK Racing Pescarolo in third place was another 18 laps further down the road. Well deserved second place.
35-OAK Racing: A troubled race for the second OAK Racing Pescarolo. Mathieu Lahaye came into the box just after half past seven in the evening and a mechanical problem kept the car in the pit for almost 12 minutes. At 2.45 the car went into the box for another 12 minutes with the team replacing several parts. One hour later mechanical problems returned and Moreau returned to the pit where the car was serviced for another 18 minutes. At 5.30 Lahaye returned to the pit again with another problem that would eventually turn out to be terminal. The Pescarolo was seen leaking oil and the team tried to change an oil pump and the turbo, but after returning to the track the car retired with an engine failure just before 8 a.m.
39-KSM: Things could not have started more worse for Kai Kruse’s team. After a big shunt in practice the race had hardly started when De Pourtales brought the car in with an oil leak and a faulty turbo. One hour was lost and the chance of a decent result was gone. Just after 5 pm a clutch problem meant another hour was lost. More time was lost in another pit stop, but then the team had an untroubled run of around 8 hours. On Sunday the team hit trouble again with the climax being a fire at the pit entry. After it was finally extinguished the car was pushed into the box where it was retired. Hours of problems finally came to an end.
40-Quifel-ASM Team: Despite being named the top Zytek car in LMP2 in our preview Le Mans 2009 was an edition the team wants to forget as soon as possible. In the first hour Guy Smith was already in the pit more than he wanted, losing valuable time. Amaral took over from Smith but spun just minutes after taking over. Half an hour later he hit the wall but was able to continue and 20 minutes after the first incident Amaral was in a tyre wall again. The damage turned out to be terminal as the team withdrew the car only a few minutes later.
41-G.A.C. Racing Team: The Zytek of Ojjeh, Gosselin and Peter was another of those LMP2 cars that did compete this year but was rather invisible and quickly disappeared. From the start to late in the evening things went reasonably well, but just after 10 p.m. the car came in when an ECU had to be changed and an exhaust problem needed attention. The problems were more serious though and at 10.54p.m. the team withdrew the Zytek with a broken engine.
Conclusion:
Once again the Porsche RS Spyder was the car required to win Le Mans in the LMP2 class (and the Michelin Green X Challenge). LMP2 was rather disappointing though with only four out of twelve entries making it to the finish. Team Essex did everything it should do and crushed the opposition. 14 laps advantage over the second placed car, 32 laps over the number three in the classification and a stunning 51 laps over fourth place need no further explanation. LMP2 was Team Essex.
Until Mazda/AER can get a fuel it’s turbos can stomach, I’d supply all it’s customers with a SCREAMINGLY slow 2 rotor motor that would loudly embarrass the ACO into solving this fuel problem.
An experienced team like RML suffering 3 straight engine failures? ‘Something’ is not right.
dh
The ACO handling of the fuel crisis for the turbo engines has been totally pathetic, this is the second season of problems.
AER have won LMP2 at Le Mans and the LMS championship before. There is no doubt they are the best turbo racing engine builders in the world, if they cannot get things to work then the future looks very bleak.
I am a big fan of turbo engines and to have a series with only normally aspirated engines would be a total disaster. Do you think Audi or Peugeot would have been allowed to suffer for so long without something being done!
Come on ACO the changes before Spa were not enough, we need a proper solution before the next race.
Here’s what I think:
#5 NAVI Porsche: such a shame they crashed with only 1 hour left
#24 OAK Pesca: fair play, 3rd in class
#25 RML Lola: they did good until the inevitable happened
#26 Radical: such a shame the Aston shoved it in2 the tyre wall
#30 Racing Box Lola: pity they were’nt as successful as they were @ 1000km of Catalunya
#31 Essex Porsche: brilliant, deserved win
#32 Barazi Zytek: consistent
#33 Speedy Lola: well done
#35 OAK Pesca: oh dear
#39 KSM Lola: lol, bad time to retire though
#40 Quifel Ginetta-Zytek: lol
#41 GAC Zytek: oh dear
Mazda engines running ok in US why not here.. Porsche needs slowing down and teams need to get their act togehther to make this class more competitive.
I think there is a different fuel in the ALMS. With the exception of Sebring, where the Mazda was several seconds per lap slower and probably not running at full boost, the ALMS races have been shorter and thus the engines may not have reached that failure point yet.
I believe the Turbo teams in LMS have been reducing boost to try and survive. Oak Mazda is a good example, they finish, but are off the pace.
Good comments from the above people
It’s fair to say that this category proves how hard it is at Le Mans, no matter if you’ve won races here or there, Le Mans is so unforgiving.
Big congrats to the Porshce Spyder, it’s a phenominal machine.
Can you please elaborate on the turbe/fuel issue?
Think some of the problem is down to the quaility of the fuel, they use diffrant fuel in the ALMS compared to the LMS, I am not sure which brands of fuel are use but it seems to be that the fuel used in the ALMS is of a high quaility than is used in the LMS, Turbo engines need a high quaility of fuel to stop pre-detination (ie spark ouccuring at the wrong time)
The fuel is not the problem. AER simply needs to produce the turbos to work with the fuel given.
The ALMS uses biofuel (petrol and ethanol mix) so all teams tune down their engines slightly to make that fuel mixture work. The Mazda AER engines were designed for the ALMS regs, so it’s time to go back to the drawing board.
But of course they’re probably waiting for the bank check from Mazda to start on that.
At Sebring and Le Mans we have seen the Mazdas can survive, but at such a cost in power it is non-competitve. The Fernandez Acura was leaping ahead of the Dyson Lola Mazdas at Sebring. Since, then, shorter races and a larger air restrictor for the Mazda have leveled the playing field. But I bet the next long race, Petite Le Mans, we’ll see the Dyson Lolas struggling again.
AER, like all engine builders, design engines based on the rules not only as they exist but also those proposed for the future. As noted by other posters, Turbos need a certain level of fuel quality to run at peak efficiency. The fuel used by the ACO when the Mazda MZR-R engines were designed and built satisfied those requirements. Clearly there is some underlying motive, either money from the fuel supplier in sponsorship dollars or the slavish adoption of Green Rules, that has created a competitive imbalance. Would Audi sit quietly by if the ACO chose a fuel that favored the Puegeot’s engine and caused damage to the Audi engine?
Here is a snippet from the Lola-Mazda website. The statement pertains to Spa but the same problems obviously continued through Le Mans
http://www.mazda-lola.com/LMS2009/LMS2009_02Spa_preview.htm
Le Mans Series 2009
Round 2. Spa-Francorchamps 1000 Kilometres. May 8th-10th 2009
Weekend Preview
While this declaration caught most pundits on the hop, the long-anticipated announcement involving an addressing of the fuel incompatibility issue in LMP2 failed to materialise. News of general dissatisfaction within LMP2 ranks broke just before Barcelona, with two teams letting it be known that they were unhappy with the way the current bio-fuel formulation favours the normally-aspirated engines. The issue was effectively confirmed by RML AD Group it its own post-race press release, which revealed that the Mazda-Lola’s engine failure at Barcelona had been attributable to the fuel incompatibility problem.
The issue first arose at Paul Ricard in March 2008, when RML’s MG Lola suffered two catastrophic engine failures during the official pre-season test. Subsequent examination by engine manufacturer AER revealed that the bio-fuel formulation, introduced new for 2008, was incompatible with the turbocharged engines. Appeals were made to the ACO to address the problem, but nothing was forthcoming, although assurances were offered that suggested the issue would be investigated. RML, in common with other teams running turbocharged engines, were left with no option but to de-tune their engines for the remainder of the season.
Frustrated by a year of having to compete with a power disadvantage of some 50 horsepower, RML announced a two-year engine deal with Mazda from November 2008. While hopes remained that the incompatibility issue really would be addressed, the Mazda unit offered the benefit of being less highly stressed than the end-of-development MG XP-21, and better able to cope with the poor quality fuel. Hopes were dashed when samples of the 2009 specification fuel were analysed, only to reveal that the quality was actually inferior to the fuel supplied in 2008, and the affect on turbocharged engines was (is) likely to be even more acute.
Proof of the pudding came with the relatively poor results achieved by the turbocharged runners at Barcelona - the best finish coming from the Bruichladdich Radical in fourth - and the engine failures suffered by both the RML and the KSM Lolas. Further appeals have been made to the ACO.
Those ACO guys really need to get their act together. If the privateer base has to buy new engines every race, they’ll soon dwindle in numbers.
I agree with Kiki. It’s not just about the ACO getting there act together, it’s about all parts working together to solve a problem, this is not this 1st time such a issue has occured with turbocharged engine with poor quaility of fuel (it happen to Porsche during the group C era)